Trust Erosion and Reputational Damage: Board Members as Guardians of Corporate Values

In this post, we will explore

key areas that underscore the significance of trust and reputation in corporate governance and how board members navigate through them.

Read more

With the high level of dynamism in the landscape of corporate governance, the erosion of trust and reputational damage can have far-reaching implications for board members and the organisations whom they govern. In recent years, Nigeria’s corporate world has witnessed numerous high-profile scandals and controversies that have highlighted the critical importance of maintaining trust and a strong reputation for corporate entities. In these times of palpable fear, uncertainty in the marketplace and upheaval in the economic outlook, it is significantly crucial that board members jealously guide and sustain the reputation and trust stakeholders impose on them to lead their organisation while upholding shared vision and goals. We will explore key areas that underscore the significance of trust and reputation in corporate governance and how board members navigate through them.

Stakeholder Confidence and Investor Relations

Trust is the bedrock upon which stakeholder confidence is built. For board members, maintaining the trust of stakeholders and investors is paramount. A tarnished reputation can lead to dwindling investor confidence, causing a decline in stock prices and potentially leading to shareholder activism. Conversely, a board that prioritises transparency, ethical conduct, and long-term value creation will most likely attract more investors, contributing to the organisation's stability and growth.

In this critical moment in our history, no company will prefer loosing stakeholders’ confidence and subsequently face its attendant consequences. Good and cordial relationship as stipulated by the Nigeria Code of Corporate Governance (NCCG 2018) is of great essence in developing and entrenching confidence and unalloyed support. To bolster trust and reputation, board members need to actively engage with stakeholders, foster open lines of communication, and be transparent in their decision-making processes. Rigorous compliance with regulations and ethical standards will also demonstrate the board's commitment to responsible governance.

Impact on Company Culture

The board sets the tone for the entire organisation, emulating their behaviour and ethical standards throughout the corporate culture. When trust is eroded at the board level, it permeates down the ranks, resulting in a toxic culture characterised by secrecy, fear, and moral ambiguity. Bad company culture is an apogee of bad corporate governance; a precursor to the south-side movement in terms of performance and viability of business. The effect of an unfavourable business environment is a plateful of challenges enough to add to the impact of bad company cultures. To prevent this, board members must lead by example and champion a culture of integrity, accountability, and inclusivity. By emphasising values that align with the organisation's mission and vision, board members can foster a positive corporate culture that attracts top talent and motivates employees to perform at their best. This great working environment impacts productivity.

Legal and Regulatory Scrutiny

Trust erosion and reputational damage can attract unwanted attention from regulatory bodies and law enforcement agencies. With volatility in the market, circumventing the rules and regulations will be tempting in order to reduce the cost incurred during production. Many organisations will fall on the wrong side of the law regulating them or required certification bodies due to defaulting in regulation requirements, standard operating procedures, or employee relations. Failure to uphold ethical standards and comply with legal requirements can lead to investigations, fines, and legal disputes, harming the organisation's bottom line and damaging its reputation in the market. These are mainly due to non-adherence to governance codes related to industries which can be traceable to the leadership and oversight function of the board members.  To mitigate such risks, board members should remain vigilant in overseeing compliance efforts, implementing robust internal controls, and conducting regular risk assessments. By proactively addressing potential legal and regulatory issues, the board can protect the organisation from reputational harm and maintain the trust of stakeholders.

Crisis Management and Resilience

No organisation is immune to crises, but how the board handles such situations can significantly impact trust and reputation. Mishandling crises, attempting cover-ups, or failing to take responsibility can irreparably damage an organisation's reputation and erode public trust. With a deficit in infrastructure development, cutting-edge technology, up-to-date technical know-how, and those who will act unethically in many industries in Nigeria, there are bound to be incidents, mishaps, near misses, accidents, and casualties that will raise health and safety concerns. Also, booms and bumps are cyclical in businesses. They are an inevitable part of businesses. Managing this complex web of crises show how resilient an organisation can be. Board members must have robust crisis management strategies in place to respond swiftly and transparently when challenges arise. By acknowledging mistakes, taking corrective actions, and communicating effectively with stakeholders during a crisis, the board can instil confidence in their ability to navigate difficult situations, thereby preserving trust and reputation.

Impact on Business Relationships

A company's success often hinges on the strength of its business relationships, whether with suppliers, customers, or partners. This intricately connected relationship ensures the smooth running of businesses. When trust is compromised, these relationships can quickly deteriorate, leading to lost business opportunities, a weakened market position, loss of market share, and most importantly reputation. Wading through this uneven relationship requires tact and experience to maintain and manage by board members. To protect the organisation's interests, board members must prioritise maintaining strong relationships with key stakeholders. Open communication, fair dealings, and a reputation for ethical conduct will not only preserve existing partnerships but also attract new opportunities for growth and collaboration.  

Trust erosion and reputation are vital concerns in corporate governance for board members. They are lubricants that help in oiling the wheels of sometimes rusty relationships of key stakeholders. Upholding trust and safeguarding reputation is not just a matter of ethical responsibility; it directly impacts the long-term viability and success of the organisation. By prioritising stakeholder confidence, fostering a positive corporate culture, complying with regulations, effectively managing crises, and nurturing business relationships, board members can steer their organisations toward sustainable growth and prosperity. In doing so, they solidify their roles as responsible stewards of corporate governance and guardians of trust and reputation.


Research and Advocacy Department, IoD Nigeria

28, Cameron Road, Ikoyi, Lagos, Nigeria

Beyond the Headlines: The Complexities of Women Board Appointments and Corporate Success